New Zealand. For many, it’s the dream trip of a lifetime. A land of soaring mountains, otherworldly fiords, geothermal wonders, and pristine beaches. It’s a long way to come and a significant investment, so it’s completely understandable that you want to see everything. You’ve seen the photos of Milford Sound and you’ve dreamed of visiting Hobbiton. You want it all.
I get it. But as someone who lives here and has explored this country extensively, I’m here to give you the single most important piece of advice for planning your trip:
Please, do not try to see both the North and South Islands in under two weeks.
It is the most common mistake tourists make, and it’s a recipe for an expensive, exhausting holiday spent staring out a car window. This guide will explain why choosing just one island for your 10-14 day trip will give you a richer, more relaxing, and far more memorable adventure.
1. The Deceptive Map: New Zealand is Much Bigger Than You Think
On a world map, New Zealand looks like two small, manageable islands. This is an illusion. The country is long and narrow. Driving from the top of the North Island (Cape Reinga) to the bottom of the South Island (Bluff) is over 2,000 kilometres and requires more than 30 hours of pure, non-stop driving.
To put it in perspective, New Zealand is roughly the same size as the United Kingdom or Italy. Would you try to see all of Italy in 10 days?
2. The Tyranny of the Drive: You’ll Live in Your Car
A typical, rushed “both islands in 12 days” itinerary looks something like this:
- Day 1: Land in Auckland, exhausted.
- Day 2: Drive to Hobbiton, then drive to Rotorua.
- Day 3: See Rotorua, then drive to Tongariro.
- Day 4: Drive to Wellington.
- Day 5: Take the ferry, then drive to Kaikoura.
- Day 6: Drive to Christchurch.
- Day 7: Drive across Arthur’s Pass to the West Coast.
- Day 8: Drive to Franz Josef Glacier.
- Day 9: Drive to Wanaka.
- Day 10: Drive to Queenstown.
- Day 11: Milford Sound day trip (an 8-hour round trip drive).
- Day 12: Fly home, exhausted.
Notice a theme? The main activity every single day is driving. You’ll spend your holiday in a constant cycle of packing, checking out, driving for 4-6 hours, checking in, and being too tired to do anything else.
3. “Google Maps Time” vs. “New Zealand Reality Time”
This is a critical point. Our roads are not straight, multi-lane highways. They are winding, single-lane roads that climb over mountains and hug the coastline. A drive that Google Maps estimates at 3 hours will realistically take 4 or more once you account for getting stuck behind a truck, navigating a one-lane bridge, and stopping for the irresistible photo opportunities. Always add at least 20% to any GPS travel time estimate.
4. The “Lost Day” of the Inter-Island Ferry
Crossing from Wellington in the North to Picton in the South isn’t a quick hop. The process realistically consumes the better part of a full day. Consider the timeline:
- Pack and check out of your Wellington hotel.
- Drive to the ferry terminal an hour before departure.
- The ferry journey itself is 3.5 hours.
- Disembarking the ferry can take another 30-45 minutes.
- You then start your drive south from Picton.
By the time you reach your next destination, an entire day of your precious holiday is gone.
5. Bad Weather Can Wreck a Tight Schedule
New Zealand weather is famously fickle. A low cloud can cancel your scenic flight. Heavy rain can close a road. If your itinerary has you in Franz Josef for only one afternoon to do a heli-hike and it gets rained out, that’s it. You have no buffer day. You just have to get in your car the next morning and leave, disappointed. A slower itinerary gives you the flexibility to wait out bad weather.
6. You’ll See Everything and Experience Nothing
This is the most important reason of all. A great holiday isn’t a checklist of places you’ve taken a photo of. It’s about the experiences you have.
Compare these two scenarios:
- Rushed Trip: You drive past a beautiful lake, take a photo from the car park, and drive on because you need to get to your hotel 3 hours away.
- Slower Trip: You arrive at the same beautiful lake. You have time to rent a kayak, go for a swim, or take the 2-hour walk around its shore. You sit and have a coffee. You actually experience the place.
The Solution: Choose One Island
So, how do you choose?
- Choose the North Island if… you’re fascinated by geothermal wonders (Rotorua), volcanoes (Tongariro), vibrant Māori culture, and stunning coastlines from golden beaches to rugged surf breaks. And, of course, Hobbiton.
- Choose the South Island if… your dream is about epic, jaw-dropping mountain landscapes, glaciers, the breathtaking fiords of Milford Sound, and world-class alpine hiking.
“But I have to see Hobbiton and Milford Sound!” I hear you. It’s better to have one incredible, deeply rewarding island experience and save the other for a future trip, rather than two rushed, stressful, and superficial ones.
The best New Zealand holiday isn’t about how many kilometres you cover, but how many memories you make. Give yourself the gift of time.
👉 Need Help Planning Your Trip?
Excursion New Zealand is your ultimate guide to an unforgettable journey. We help you discover top attractions, hidden gems, and local favorites to maximize your New Zealand adventure.
How it works is you enter you starting origin, destination and it will show you an optimized route and any attractions along the way.
From there you can select what attractions you want to see and we provide you with a plan including the travel time required.
